He Caught It Before He Spoke

Gary sat across from me at our first session. By every outward measure, he looked like someone who didn't need to be there.

He'd built his team from four people to seventeen over six years. Retention was high, deadlines were met, and two of his direct reports had been promoted into leadership roles elsewhere because of what they'd learned under him. He walked me through his accomplishments with the fluency of someone confident in his background.

Then, almost as an aside: "My boss recommended this, but I don't really know what I'm supposed to be working on with you. I think I've kind of... arrived?"

He said it lightly, but something underneath it wasn't light at all. I asked what it might mean if it turned out he hadn't arrived.

He didn't answer right away.

That's a harder question than it sounds, and not just for Gary. The most capable people carry the most to lose by admitting they still have something to learn. Someone newer to the work can say "I got that wrong" and file it under learning the job. Someone who has spent a decade being the reliable one, the person whose judgment other people trust, pays a steeper price for the same sentence.

Growth for them may be triggered by a public problem. Then a boss who recalibrates how much confidence to extend and colleagues who remember the incident longer than they should.  It can also hit your self-image, forcing it to make room for having been wrong.

This is the unique trap of high functioning. The better we get, the more expensive it becomes to admit we're not finished getting better. Once our competence becomes visible, it starts to calcify into something we protect rather than something we keep building.

Gary was about to find out how true this is. The question sat with him for two weeks but he found his answer in a regular meeting.

His team usually met deadlines and delivered decent work. They’d always functioned well together, but something in the group felt off. Answers came too quickly and issues got smoothed over. Nobody pushed back.

Things crystallized when he asked a direct report a question. She answered in a way that was careful, hedged, technically accurate but completely unhelpful. Afterward, he pulled her aside and asked what she actually thought.

She paused before answering, and that pause told him everything.

He realized his team wasn't really performing well. They were performing safely. And those aren't the same thing. A safe environment allows difficulty to be expressed.

People are exquisitely sensitive to what a leader's behavior signals, whatever the leader intends, and they learn the real rules quickly. Alan Mulally, former CEO of Ford, used to say “you can't manage a secret.” The things people are afraid to share don't disappear. They accumulate. And the people who stop talking aren’t the problem. They’re the evidence.

What It Already Cost Him

For a decade, Gary's authority had rested on being the person with the answer. But he told me about a later meeting where he'd floated an idea he wasn't certain about. He told the group about his uncertainty instead of presenting the idea as settled. A junior member pushed back on the suggestion.

Gary’s instinct was to defend but he didn't give into it. He found sitting with it was harder than his usual approach. Being paused publicly by someone eleven years into her career, then discovering the pause was earned, cost him something he hadn't expected to lose.

He spent the next fifteen minutes running the exchange back, checking whether he'd been wrong or just embarrassed. It took him the rest of the afternoon to admit it was both.

Recognizing the need to learn cost him the comfortable version of himself: the one who was always slightly ahead of everyone else.

The pushback turned out to be right. And that single exchange did more to shift the group than anything Gary had previously said about openness.

But a harder cost was waiting in the past, once he saw how the team had been dancing around him.

Six months earlier, he had pushed the team to launch a new service line ahead of a competitor's expected announcement, overriding a timing concern only one person had raised. The launch had stumbled badly, but he’d filed it away as poor luck, knowing he’d made the right, decisive call.

Now he found himself replaying that decision. Had the concern been more substantial than it sounded, softened on its way to him because everyone in the room had learned that decisiveness was what got rewarded? He would probably never know, and not knowing was its own kind of cost.

The cost of a decision doesn't end when the decision works out. Sometimes it only begins.

What It Will Keep Costing Him

What Gary came to understand was that he hadn't needed to punish anyone to produce a careful team. His fluency and confidence, his comfort in the room, had done the teaching on their own. He couldn't opt out of shaping the group simply by not doing anything wrong.

So the new behavior wasn't a technique he could adopt once and move past. It was a discipline he had to keep choosing, meeting after meeting. The old reflex, stay calm, look unbothered, manage the room, never fully went away..

Three weeks later, someone told him a deadline was going to slip badly because of a decision he'd made. The old reflex was already halfway to the surface when he caught himself reaching for it. Instead, he thanked her and asked what she needed from him to fix it. He told me it still didn't feel natural. It just felt like the more honest of two available versions of himself.

Practice Invitation

Think about the cost you might be carrying in each direction Gary was.

In the present: what does someone risk when they bring you an uncomfortable truth today, and what have you been unable to see because it never reached you?

In the past: is there a decision you've filed away as settled that you've never let yourself fully re-examine, not because you're sure it was right, but because you're not sure you want to know?

And going forward: growth isn't a threshold you cross once. It's a discipline you keep choosing, in settings that will keep testing whether you meant it.  When will you next need to adapt?

*******

that’s The Gist of It™ .

Thank you for reading. If this resonated with you, I’d be honored if you’d forward it to someone who might appreciate it. Subscribe below to receive these weekly:​

Marilyn Gist